I would give it an 85,
Check tabs below for tidbits.
(and for the love of god leave handsome jack alone, he was a great villain, we know, but the horse has long been dead.)
- This didn't fit in Positives
Kept the base of the borderlands formula we love
Spiced up the "how" of it (Higher Quality Quest, Random optional "Encounters")
Very stable on launch, not a lot of bugs
Different Character Combat System keeps things new
WAAAY better story and characters then 3
Overworld is a new mode of exploration and transportation that beats the dry open lands of previous titles
-This didn't fit in negatives
Enemies can be bullet spongy without the right gear
No dedicated loot drops
Framerate could be better in some areas
Noticeable balance issues with weapon types and parts
(and for the love of god leave handsome jack alone, he was a great villain, we know, but the horse has long been dead.)